English
2025.03.04
Technical Comparative Analysis of Velocity Water Meters and Positive Displacement Water Meters
速度式水表与容积式水表技术对比分析
Technical Comparative Analysis of Velocity Water Meters and Positive Displacement Water Meters
一、基本原理与结构
1.1 速度式水表 (Velocity Water Meter)
工作原理：基于流体动力学原理，通过测量水流速度推算流量。当水流经过计量腔时驱动叶轮/涡轮旋转，转速与流速成正比。
典型结构：
- 单流束式：水流单通道冲击叶轮（精度±2%）
- 多流束式：水流多通道均匀驱动叶轮（精度±1.5%）
- 涡轮式：轴向水流驱动高精度涡轮（精度±1%）
- Woltman式：大口径水平/垂直涡轮结构（DN50-DN500）
Working Principle: Based on hydrodynamics, calculating flow by measuring water velocity. Water flow drives impeller/turbine rotation in metering chamber, with rotational speed proportional to flow velocity.
Typical Structures:
- Single-jet type: Single-channel flow impacts impeller (Accuracy ±2%)
- Multi-jet type: Multi-channel flow evenly drives impeller (Accuracy ±1.5%)
- Turbine type: Axial flow drives high-precision turbine (Accuracy ±1%)
- Woltman type: Large-diameter horizontal/vertical turbine (DN50-DN500)
1.2 容积式水表 (Positive Displacement Water Meter)
工作原理：采用机械隔离测量法，通过精确计量固定容积的流体空间实现累计计量。
典型结构：
- 活塞式：往复活塞分隔计量室（精度±0.5%）
- 旋转活塞式：椭圆形活塞与计量室内壁形成月牙腔
- 章动盘式：圆盘在锥形腔内的章动运动
- 双转子式：两个8字形转子反向旋转（工业级标准）
Working Principle: Using mechanical isolation method, achieving cumulative measurement by precisely metering fixed-volume fluid spaces.
Typical Structures:
- Piston type: Reciprocating piston divides metering chamber (Accuracy ±0.5%)
- Rotary piston type: Oval piston forming crescent chambers with inner wall
- Nutating disc type: Disc nutates in conical chamber
- Twin-rotor type: Two figure-8 rotors counter-rotating (Industrial grade)
二、性能特征对比
2.1 速度式水表优势
- 压损特性：流线型结构带来0.03-0.1MPa低压损
- 量程比：可达Q3/Q1=100:1（电子式可达250:1）
- 经济性：制造成本比容积式低30-50%
- 大流量适应性：DN500口径最大流量可达3000m³/h
Advantages:
- Pressure loss: Streamlined structure with 0.03-0.1MPa low pressure drop
- Turndown ratio: Up to Q3/Q1=100:1 (250:1 for electronic types)
- Cost-effectiveness: 30-50% lower manufacturing cost
- High-flow capacity: Max 3000m³/h for DN500 models
2.2 容积式水表优势
- 计量精度：在Q2-Q4范围内可达0.5级精度
- 始动流量：可检测0.5L/h的微小流量
- 流体兼容性：可测量高粘度液体（达100cSt）
- 抗干扰性：不受管道振动和电磁干扰影响
Advantages:
- Accuracy: Class 0.5 accuracy in Q2-Q4 range
- Start-up flow: Detect minimum 0.5L/h flow
- Fluid compatibility: Measure high-viscosity liquids (up to 100cSt)
- Anti-interference: Immune to pipeline vibration and EMI
三、关键技术差异
对比维度 | 速度式水表 | 容积式水表 |
测量原理 | 流速-体积换算 | 容积直接计量 |
运动部件 | 叶轮/涡轮单轴旋转 | 活塞/转子复合运动 |
精度曲线 | 高流速区精度稳定 | 全量程线性精度 |
水质要求 | 需过滤＞100μm颗粒 | 需过滤＞50μm颗粒 |
维护周期 | 5-8年（机械式） | 3-5年（需润滑维护） |
温度适应性 | -30℃~+90℃ | -10℃~+60℃ |
Key Technical Differences:
Aspect | Velocity Meter | Positive Displacement |
Principle | Velocity-volume conversion | Direct volume measurement |
Moving parts | Single-axis impeller | Complex piston/rotor motion |
Accuracy curve | Stable at high flow | Linear full-range accuracy |
Water quality | Filter＞100μm particles | Filter＞50μm particles |
Maintenance | 5-8 years (mechanical) | 3-5 years (lubrication) |
Temperature | -30℃~+90℃ | -10℃~+60℃ |
四、应用场景推荐
4.1 速度式水表典型应用
- 市政供水管网：DN40-DN500主干管网监测
- 工业循环水：电厂冷却水系统（流量＞100m³/h）
- 农业灌溉：喷灌/滴灌系统（含沙量＜5kg/m³）
- 建筑给水：高层建筑分区计量（需加装整流器）
Typical Applications:
- Municipal water supply networks (DN40-DN500)
- Industrial circulation systems (＞100m³/h)
- Agricultural irrigation (sand content＜5kg/m³)
- Building water supply (with flow conditioner)
4.2 容积式水表典型应用
- 居民户用计量：1.5级精度冷水表（Q3=2.5m³/h）
- 商业综合体：空调冷媒水计量（粘度1-10cSt）
- 食品制药行业：CIP清洗系统（需卫生级认证）
- 预付费系统：物联网智能水表（脉冲信号输出）
Typical Applications:
- Residential metering (Class 1.5, Q3=2.5m³/h)
- Commercial HVAC systems (1-10cSt viscosity)
- Food/pharmaceutical CIP systems (sanitary grade)
- Prepayment IoT smart meters (pulse output)
五、技术发展趋势
- 复合式设计：速度式+容积式的组合计量（如Badger Meter的HYBRID技术）
- 无磁传感：采用光学编码或电感式信号采集（解决磁铁退磁问题）
- 自供电技术：涡轮发电+超级电容储能（EN 1434标准认证）
- 数字孪生：内置流量自诊断算法（ISO 4064:2017标准）
Development Trends:
- Hybrid design: Combined velocity+displacement (e.g. Badger Meter HYBRID)
- Non-magnetic sensing: Optical/inductive signal acquisition
- Self-powering: Turbine generation + supercapacitor (EN 1434)
- Digital twin: Embedded flow diagnostics (ISO 4064:2017)
Contact
Leave your information and we will contact you.
WhatsApp
TEL
WeChat
Email